How Gulp Data’s Valuation Could Have Prevented a $175M Fraud in M&A

Welcome to the Data Depths, a newsletter covering news, insights, and strategies related to managing Data as an Asset™ and understanding how a company's data contributes to Enterprise Value. View previous posts here.

Sent this by a friend? Sign up here for free!

How a Gulp Data Valuation Could Have Prevented a $175M Fraud in M&A

The recent example of the Frank fraud trial underscores the critical need for data valuation as a standard due diligence (DD) item in M&A transactions, particularly when the target company’s value is tied to its data assets.

The Case: JP Morgan & Frank – A $175M Lesson

In 2021, JP Morgan Chase acquired Frank, a startup claiming to have 4.25 million student users, for $175 million. However, it later emerged that this number was wildly inflated, with the real figure closer to 300,000 users. To bridge the gap, fraudulent email lists were allegedly fabricated, misleading JP Morgan’s acquisition team. The deception only became apparent post-transaction when emails sent to Frank’s “users” received abnormally low engagement, triggering an internal review.

How Gulp Data’s Valuation Would Have Flagged This Fraud

Had Gulp Data’s Data Valuation Service been implemented as part of due diligence, this scenario could have been prevented. Here’s how:

1. Transaction Value vs. Data Quality Analysis
   

   • We specialize in assessing whether the data justifies the valuation by looking at user uniqueness, engagement levels, and monetization potential.

   • If Frank had undergone our analysis, it would have been clear that their data valuation did not align with a $175M purchase price.

2. Anomaly Detection for Synthetic or Fake Data
   

   • Our proprietary AI-driven verification process checks for synthetic data patterns (e.g., mass-generated email addresses, unnatural usage spikes, and duplicate accounts).

   • In this case, we would have exposed the fabrication of fake email accounts before the deal closed.

Why Data Valuation Should Be a Standard DD Item in M&A

This case is a clear wake-up call for investors, PE firms, and corporations engaging in data-heavy acquisitions. Companies are often acquired based on the perceived value of their data assets, yet many deals lack independent data verification. A proper valuation ensures:

✔️ Fraud prevention by exposing manipulated or non-existent assets.
✔️ Accurate pricing and risk mitigation in M&A transactions.
✔️ A more defensible valuation for post-acquisition performance tracking.

At Gulp Data, we believe data valuation should be non-negotiable in any transaction where data is a key asset.

At Gulp Data, we specialize in helping businesses unlock the true potential of their data assets. Whether you're preparing for a sale or evaluating a target, our expert data valuation and monetization services ensure you don't leave value on the table.

 Stay in touch with us:

• ➡️ Newsletter signup

• ➡️ Schedule with a Gulp executive 

• ➡️ Buy Data 

• ➡️ Get a Data Valuation